Recently read Hawthorne’s The House of the Seven Gables. Not impressed. Pedantic, some themes grossly over-worked, others completely neglected and confusing. Who is this daguerrotypist, anyway? Hawthorne failed to synthesize this anomalous character into the plot. And the analysis of the released convict was horrifying – in that it was largely irrelevant and ponderously overdeveloped. I remember appreciating The Scarlet Letter, as period piece, if nothing else. Seven Gables was a chore.
I also just read Lowell Bair’s translation of Victor Hugo’s Hunchback of Notre Dame. The book was wonderful. The translation was awful. I haven’t read anything else of Hugo’s, but I simply cannot believe that a storyteller of his caliber could possibly be such a clumsy writer. No rhythm, no flow, insufficient punctuation. In addition, I didn’t discover until I was finished with the book that the edition was abridged. Thanks, Bantam Classics, for completely mangling my reading experience once again.